Visa and Mastercard are among the most widely recognised payment networks worldwide, providing a variety of services beyond traditional credit and debit cards. Each company has developed distinct features and partnerships, enabling financial institutions to issue cards with different benefits, fee structures, and reward programmes. While both networks offer essential services such as transaction processing and security features, key differences in their operational models, card levels, and contactless payment technologies distinguish them.
Key Takeaways
- Global Recognition: Visa and Mastercard are prominent payment networks that provide transaction processing, security features, and mobile wallet options, with some variations in operational models and contactless payment technologies.
- Revenue Generation: Both Visa and Mastercard generate revenue through interchange fees, charging banks for card issuance and transaction processing. These costs are typically passed on to merchants, impacting their profit margins.
- Acceptance in South Africa: Most businesses in South Africa accept both Visa and Mastercard. However, some small and medium enterprises (SMEs) may prefer one network over the other, depending on fee structures and local bank partnerships.
About Arcadia Finance
Get the right loan without hassle through Arcadia Finance. With no application fees, select from 16 reputable lenders approved by South Africa’s National Credit Regulator. Experience a quick, reliable service tailored to your needs.
Overview of Mastercard
Mastercard was established in 1966 by a consortium of banks aiming to enhance their competitive stance against Visa, which was the dominant player in payment processing at that time. Until its public offering in 2006, Mastercard functioned as a cooperative, owned by more than 25,000 financial institutions that issued its cards to consumers.
Today, Mastercard operates as a global payment technology platform, offering prepaid, debit, and credit card services, as well as a variety of business and financial services worldwide. By the end of December 2020, Mastercard’s credit purchase volume in the U.S. reached R14.4 trillion ($837 billion), with net revenue amounting to R284.3 billion ($15.3 billion).
Since Mastercard does not directly issue cards, it does not earn revenue from cardholder transactions. Instead, it generates income by charging banks fees for card issuance and payment processing. These fees, known as interchange or ‘swipe’ fees, are collected at various stages of the payment process, including when transactions are authorised and funds are settled in accounts.
Overview of Visa
Visa is the second-largest credit card network globally, accounting for 50% of all card payments, following China’s UnionPay, which surpassed Visa in 2015. Currently, there are 3.9 billion Visa-branded cards in circulation, issued by nearly 15,000 financial institutions.
Visa’s origins date back to 1958 when it was launched by Bank of America. The program expanded as this payment system was licensed to other financial institutions, ultimately evolving into the independent financial services corporation we know today. In addition to offering prepaid, debit, and credit cards, Visa provides a wide range of services, including ATMs, retail partnerships, fraud prevention, and business insights.
Like Mastercard, Visa generates revenue by charging fees to card issuers for transaction processing. These fees are typically passed on to merchants that accept Visa payments.
Both Visa and Mastercard employ cutting-edge technology to ensure your financial safety, but scams are always evolving. Learn how to protect yourself by reading the most common credit card scams.
What Are the Similarities Between Visa and Mastercard?
The Visa and Mastercard logos are a familiar sight at checkout counters worldwide, representing two of the most significant payment networks. Here’s what these two companies have in common:
Neither Network Sets Cardholder Terms and Conditions
Visa and Mastercard do not directly issue their own credit or debit cards. Instead, they provide a licensing framework and the technology banks use to process transactions between customers and merchants. Financial institutions, such as banks or credit unions, manage Visa and Mastercard cards. These entities serve as the card issuers, responsible for setting fees, determining interest rates, and structuring any available rewards programs for their cardholders.
Wide Acceptance Across the Globe
Both Visa and Mastercard are recognized and accepted in nearly every country due to their extensive global networks. Merchants displaying the Visa or Mastercard logos are required to accept these cards, regardless of the issuing bank or the country of origin. This broad acceptance makes Visa and Mastercard reliable options for international travel, providing greater accessibility compared to networks with more restricted acceptance, such as Discover or Capital One. As a result, they are dependable payment choices when traveling abroad.
Fees and Reward Tiers
As previously mentioned, banks issuing Visa and Mastercard credit cards determine their own fee structures and associated benefits. Generally, most credit card offers are categorized into four main types:
- Low-fee Credit Cards: These cards have fewer benefits but typically feature lower fees and interest rates. They often offer added flexibility, such as balance transfer options and customizable repayment terms.
- Premium Credit Cards: These cards generally come with higher credit limits and annual fees but offer valuable perks, such as concierge services, extended warranties, or access to rental vehicles.
- Rewards Credit Cards: Ideal for consumers looking to earn cashback or loyalty points through everyday purchases like groceries or utility bills.
- Frequent Flyer Credit Cards: These focus on travel-related rewards, allowing cardholders to accumulate points for flights or other travel benefits, often through a bank’s airline partner. Additional benefits may include travel insurance, lost luggage coverage, or emergency assistance.
Digital Payment Options
As mobile and contactless payments gain popularity, Visa and Mastercard have broadened their services beyond traditional card transactions to cater to evolving customer preferences. Mastercard has rolled out Tap & Go Payments, which are comparable to Visa’s Contactless Indicator cards. Additionally, both companies have enhanced their offerings by integrating with mobile wallets like Apple Pay, Google Pay, and Samsung Pay, providing customers with more flexible payment options.
Security Features
Visa and Mastercard offer a range of security benefits, driven by regulatory standards and market competition. Common security features include:
- Purchase Protection: If your card details are used for unauthorised or fraudulent purchases, Visa and Mastercard cover most chargebacks when reported to the issuing bank. Mastercard offers this protection across all its cards, with the most comprehensive coverage available through World and World Elite Mastercard options. Visa also provides trip cancellation or interruption coverage as an additional benefit.
- Mobile Phone Protection: Many credit card companies, including Citi and Chase, as well as Visa and Mastercard, offer insurance for mobile phones against theft or damage.
- Return Protection: This benefit applies when cardholders are unable to return items purchased with their card. Mastercard has a Satisfaction Guarantee policy, refunding claims made within 60 days of purchase, while Visa Infinite and Visa Signature cards provide return protection within 90 days.
Ever wondered how carrying a positive balance could impact your spending? Discover how this strategy can play in your favor in our guide about maintaining a positive balance on credit cards.
Points of Difference Between Visa and Mastercard
Visa and Mastercard can be distinguished by several key factors:
| Category | Visa | Mastercard |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Acceptance | ||
| Number of Countries | Accepted in around 200 countries | Accepted in more than 210 countries |
| Merchant Acceptance | Widely accepted by millions of merchants worldwide | Comparable acceptance across global merchants |
| Regional Preference | Stronger presence in some parts of North America and Asia | Slight edge in parts of Europe and South America |
| 2. Card Features and Benefits | ||
| Reward Programs | Varies by issuer but often focuses on travel and cashback rewards | Includes retail-focused rewards, travel points, and cashback offers |
| Travel Perks | Premium cards (e.g., Visa Infinite) offer travel insurance, hotel benefits, and airport lounge access | World Elite Mastercard offers similar benefits, including lounge access and travel protection |
| Concierge Services | Available with Visa Platinum and Visa Infinite cards | Available with World and World Elite Mastercards |
| Card Levels | Visa Classic, Gold, Platinum, Infinite | Standard, World, World Elite |
| 3. Fees and Exchange Rates | ||
| Foreign Transaction Fees | Typically 1-3%, though premium cards may waive fees | Similar range of 1-3%, with some premium cards offering no foreign fees |
| Currency Exchange Rates | Updated daily; competitive but can vary slightly | Generally offers slightly better exchange rates, though differences are minimal |
| Other Fees | Fees are set by the issuing bank, not Visa | Fees depend on the issuing bank, not Mastercard |
Which One Should You Choose?
When deciding between Visa and Mastercard, it’s important to understand that neither is inherently “better” than the other. Instead, the right choice largely depends on several key factors, including your personal preferences, the issuing bank, the rewards and benefits on offer, and how you plan to use the card.
When Visa Might Be Better
- If your bank or credit union has a stronger partnership with Visa and offers better rewards or lower fees on Visa cards.
- Some cards may come with access to exclusive events or discounts in specific sectors, such as sports and entertainment.
- Visa is often preferred in certain regions, such as parts of Asia, so if you travel frequently to these areas, Visa might be the better choice.
When Mastercard Might Excel
- Mastercard offers premium tiers like World Elite Mastercard, which can provide additional perks such as enhanced travel insurance, airport lounge access, and luxury hotel benefits.
- Mastercard may have better regional acceptance in some areas, including parts of Europe and Canada.
- If your bank issues a high-tier Mastercard with features that align with your lifestyle, such as dining rewards or cashback offers, it could be the more practical option.
The Issuer’s Terms Are Key
It’s important to remember that Visa and Mastercard only serve as payment networks—they do not issue cards themselves. This means that the actual terms, fees, and rewards depend on the issuing bank or financial institution. Comparing individual card offers from different banks is essential, as a Mastercard issued by one bank may have very different benefits from a Mastercard issued by another.
Ultimately, choosing between Visa and Mastercard should come down to what best aligns with your financial goals, lifestyle, and how you plan to use the card.
Card Benefits for South African Consumers
Visa and Mastercard provide a range of benefits to South African cardholders, designed to enhance the convenience and value of everyday transactions. Both networks offer cashback rewards, allowing consumers to earn back a percentage of their spending on certain purchases, which is especially beneficial for frequent shoppers. Additionally, cardholders can participate in rewards points programs that enable users to accumulate points redeemable for various items, including retail vouchers, travel tickets, or discounts on future purchases.
For South African consumers who travel, both Visa and Mastercard offer significant travel-related perks. These include access to travel insurance for international trips, often covering emergencies such as lost luggage, delayed flights, or medical assistance abroad. Premium cardholders may also enjoy exclusive access to airport lounges, adding comfort during travel.
Moreover, both networks provide enhanced security features, including fraud protection and purchase protection, offering peace of mind when making online or in-store transactions. South African cardholders can also benefit from contactless payment technology, making day-to-day purchases quicker and more secure. The growing availability of mobile wallet integration, such as Apple Pay and Samsung Pay, further enhances flexible payment options.
Conclusion
While Visa and Mastercard are two of the most widely accepted payment networks worldwide, their operational models, fee structures, and technology offerings reveal key distinctions that set them apart. Both networks deliver valuable services to financial institutions and cardholders, providing a range of benefits and robust security features. Visa and Mastercard offer reliable and trusted payment solutions, but the right choice will depend on individual preferences and specific business requirements.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between Visa and Mastercard?
Visa and Mastercard are both payment networks that facilitate transactions between merchants and financial institutions. The primary difference lies in their operational models, particularly their fee structures and partnerships. Visa enjoys slightly broader global circulation, while Mastercard focuses on unique offerings like its World and World Elite programs. However, for everyday users, the differences are minimal, as both networks are widely accepted around the globe.
Does Visa or Mastercard offer better rewards programmes?
Both Visa and Mastercard provide rewards programs, but the specific benefits depend on the card issuer rather than the payment network itself. Banks or financial institutions determine the rewards, which can vary across different cards. Both networks have premium card tiers, such as Visa Infinite and World Elite Mastercard, that offer enhanced rewards like travel benefits; however, the actual offerings depend on the issuing bank.
Are Visa and Mastercard accepted everywhere?
Visa and Mastercard are accepted by most merchants worldwide, including in South Africa. Both networks have extensive global reach, and any retailer displaying the Visa or Mastercard logo will accept the corresponding card, making them ideal for international travel. They are more widely accepted than smaller networks like Discover or American Express.
Which network offers better security features: Visa or Mastercard?
Both Visa and Mastercard provide strong security features, including fraud protection, purchase protection, and enhanced security for online shopping. Mastercard offers SecureCode, while Visa uses Verified by Visa. These features add additional layers of security for cardholders, although the protection often depends on the specific policies of the card issuer.
Do Visa and Mastercard charge different fees for transactions?
The fees charged by Visa and Mastercard are generally similar, but the actual costs depend on the financial institutions issuing the cards. Both networks impose interchange fees, which are passed on to merchants. While there may be slight differences in fees between Visa and Mastercard, these variations are often negligible for everyday consumers.
Fast, uncomplicated, and trustworthy loan comparisons
At Arcadia Finance, you can compare loan offers from multiple lenders with no obligation and free of charge. Get a clear overview of your options and choose the best deal for you.
Fill out our form today to easily compare interest rates from 16 banks and find the right loan for you.
