The South African rand has come under significant pressure, with concerns over the stability of the Government of National Unity (GNU) undermining the local currency. According to analysis from Investec chief economist Annabel Bishop, political uncertainty at home is currently exerting more downward pressure on the rand than the global market instability caused by United States policy decisions. This signals a critical shift in investor sentiment, where domestic politics are now seen as a more immediate threat than global economic shocks.
Key Takeaways
- Rand Faces Political Headwinds: Despite global conditions that should favour a stronger rand, internal political instability—particularly tensions within the Government of National Unity—has pushed the currency beyond R19.40 to the dollar.
- Market Confidence Hinges on DA–ANC Deal: The threat of the Democratic Alliance exiting the unity government is seen as a major risk. Investors favour a continued partnership between the ANC and DA to preserve policy stability and economic credibility.
- Worst-Case Scenario Could Sink Rand to R22: If the DA exits and the ANC partners with more radical parties like the EFF or MK Party, the rand could breach R22 to the dollar, triggering significant investor pullback and heightened fears of a leftward policy shift.
About Arcadia Finance
Need a loan? Arcadia Finance makes it easy! Skip the fees and choose from 19 reliable lenders, all approved by South Africa’s National Credit Regulator. We simplify the process so you can get the funds you need—stress-free.
Bishop noted that recent developments in the United States—specifically, the imposition of broad trade tariffs by President Donald Trump on 2 April—triggered notable weakness in the US dollar. Under normal circumstances, such dollar weakness would benefit the rand, potentially driving it closer to R17.50 per US dollar. However, South Africa’s internal political challenges have overwhelmed these international effects, pushing the rand well above R19.40 per dollar instead.
Tariffs Backfire as Recession Fears Hit the US Dollar
Trump’s decision to implement new tariffs was intended to stimulate local manufacturing and strengthen both the dollar and American markets. However, the policy has backfired, sparking widespread fears of an economic recession. This has significantly weakened the US dollar across global markets. In isolation, this development would normally bolster the rand’s performance. Instead, ongoing instability within South Africa’s governing coalition has prevented the local currency from capitalising on this shift. This missed opportunity underscores how South Africa is squandering rare moments of international advantage due to its internal disarray.
Bishop emphasised that the rand’s current position—hovering above R19.00 per dollar—is not due to external economic conditions but rather a direct result of intensifying domestic political risk. Among major emerging market currencies, the rand is presently the worst performer, reflecting market anxiety over the fragility of the GNU and the growing likelihood of a break between the African National Congress (ANC) and the Democratic Alliance (DA). Foreign investors are increasingly pricing in the possibility of fiscal mismanagement, stalled reforms, and a left-leaning economic agenda—none of which bode well for long-term economic stability.
GNU Faces Crisis as DA Opposition Mounts
The core concern among investors is the possible withdrawal or expulsion of the DA from the unity government. Last week, the DA voted against the budget proposal supported by the ANC-led GNU, signalling a breakdown in cooperation between the two main parties. Although the budget was eventually passed with the help of smaller parliamentary parties, this outcome did not reassure markets. Rather, it indicated that the ANC could be preparing to move forward without the DA, raising fears of a fragmented and unstable administration. This scenario conjures up a nightmarish policy gridlock, where populist demands clash with economic pragmatism—effectively paralysing the state’s ability to govern.
Losing the DA Threatens the GNU’s Stability
A GNU that excludes the DA would lose its supermajority, forcing the ANC to rely on slim and uncertain parliamentary margins to advance legislation. This could lead to frequent policy gridlock, coalition infighting, and heightened unpredictability—conditions that are typically regarded as unfavourable by investors and ratings agencies alike. Bishop observed that if it were not for the potential departure of the DA, the rand would have been trading significantly stronger, likely below R18.00 per dollar, even after accounting for the global market turbulence caused by the US tariffs.
Such fragility raises red flags for credit rating agencies and could lead to further downgrades, capital flight, and elevated borrowing costs for the state.
Ongoing Negotiations Offer Little Market Relief
Talks over the future of the GNU continue, with both parties under pressure to find common ground. However, expectations for a resolution remain uncertain. Bishop cautioned that if the DA were to formally exit the unity government, the impact on financial markets would likely be severe. A breakdown in negotiations would increase the risk of a sudden market shock, and could result in a major loss of investor confidence. Already, large institutional investors are said to be shifting funds to safer havens, anticipating volatility, tighter monetary conditions, and slower economic growth.
Cabinet Changes Loom Amid Growing Tensions
Should the parties fail to reach agreement, a cabinet reshuffle is widely expected. The DA has expressed an interest in remaining within the GNU but would require concessions, particularly around its role and influence in economic matters. On the other hand, some elements within the ANC appear to prefer a coalition without the DA, increasing the risk of a deepening political split.
If this hardline view gains traction, markets fear that fiscal conservatism could be sidelined in favour of populist policy experiments, with damaging consequences for public finances.
ANC Deliberations Expected to Drive Market Reactions
The ANC has scheduled a working group meeting for Monday to discuss the matter. Financial markets are likely to respond swiftly depending on the outcome of these talks. Any indication of the DA’s exclusion from the GNU is expected to trigger further rand depreciation, potentially taking the currency past the psychologically significant level of R20.00 to the dollar. With investor confidence already on a knife-edge, even subtle signs of ANC–DA disengagement could trigger sharp sell-offs across bonds, equities, and currency markets.
Rand Could Breach R22 in Event of Political Fallout
According to Bishop’s forecast, a formal DA exit could drive the rand to R21.00 against the dollar almost immediately. Should the ANC opt to partner with more radical political forces, such as the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) or the MK Party, the rand may weaken beyond R22.00 per dollar. Such a development would send a strong negative signal to financial markets, raising concerns over a potential shift towards less market-friendly economic policies. The inclusion of anti-market elements in the GNU could deter foreign direct investment, hinder structural reforms, and trigger medium-term economic stagnation.
From a market perspective, the most stable and reassuring outcome would be a renewed commitment to cooperation between the DA and ANC. Investors view a continued partnership between the two parties—with the DA retaining some degree of policy influence—as the least disruptive path forward. Nonetheless, increasing resistance within ANC ranks to this compromise suggests that South Africa’s political outlook may remain uncertain in the weeks ahead. If compromise fails, the consequences may stretch beyond currency weakness to include stalled infrastructure projects, lower business confidence, and social instability driven by rising unemployment.
Conclusion
South Africa’s currency is now being shaped more by internal political drama than global economic trends. While international factors like US dollar weakness would ordinarily support the rand, domestic uncertainty surrounding the future of the GNU has reversed any potential gains. The outcome of negotiations between the ANC and DA will be critical in determining whether the rand stabilises or spirals further, with investors watching closely for signs of either compromise or collapse.
Fast, uncomplicated, and trustworthy loan comparisons
At Arcadia Finance, you can compare loan offers from multiple lenders with no obligation and free of charge. Get a clear overview of your options and choose the best deal for you.
Fill out our form today to easily compare interest rates from 19 banks and find the right loan for you.
